INDEX TO BUILDINGS AND SITES

These Buildings & Sites in the Worthington Historical Society archives are available to researchers by appointment. These files contain quite varied information on sites that has been given to us by researchers. Some are quite thick and others contain only one or two items. Most of this is secondary material, some from printed sources, some from oral family histories. Some of the photos are from newspapers and some are photocopies of originals in our archives. Buildings may be referenced by address or by the familiar name used.  Some buildings names have changed over time, so if you do not see a building you are researching, please contact the Society.  Photocopies of text and scans of original photos may be made for a charge depending on the number of pages copied or scanned. Contact info@worthingtonhistory.org

• Updated 9/18/2025

• Sites by Address

  • 335 Bristol Way

  • 95 E. Dublin Granville Road

  • 119 E. Dublin Granville Road

  • 120 E. Dublin Granville Road

  • 151 E Dublin Granville Road

  • 211 E Dublin Granville Road

  • 430 E Dublin Granville Road- Harding Home

  • 445 E Dublin Granville  Road-Red Brick Harding Home

  • 63 W Dublin Granville Road

  • 93 W Dublin Granville Road

  • 100 W Dublin Granville Road

  • 115 W Dublin Granville Road

  • 155 W Dublin Granville Road

  • 630 Evening Street

  • 661 Evening Street

  • 672 Evening Street

  • 153 Franklin Avenue see 878 High Street (house moved)

  • 158 Franklin Avenue

  • 281 Franklin Avenue (demo)

  • 580 Hartford Street

  • 620 Hartford Street

  • 628 Hartford Street see Vertical file-P and F- Dietrick, John

  • 782 Hartford Street see Hannah Bishop House

  • 544 High Street

  • 547 High Street

  • 556 High Street

  • 571 High Street-See also-Vertical File-People and Families-Asbury, Thomas and Ann

  • 615 High Street (Maple Lee Flowers)

  • 635 High Street (Leasure Drug Store) see also Vertical File-Worthington History-Post Offices)

  • 640 High Street

  • 656 High Street

  • 671-673 High Street (Morrow Home and Office) see also Vertical File-People and Families-Morrow, Dr. Thomas

  • 679-685 High Street see  Kilbourn Commercial Building 

  • 691-693 High Street (Jones Building)

  • 692 High Street

  • 695 High Street-formally a carriage house

  • 711 High Street

  • 777 High Street see Griswold Center

  • 752 High Street

  • 808 High Street

  • 825 High Street see Brundage Tavern

  • 878 High Street

  • 1033 High Street-see Vertical File-Schools-Worthington Methodist Children’s Home

  • 6880 High Street see Vertical File-Worthington History-Businesses- J.Liu

  • 207 Lakeridge Road

  • 62 E Lincoln Avenue (Columbus) see Vertical File-Buildings and Sites-Chase Houses

  • 563 Morning Street

  • 670 Morning Street

  • 680 Morning Street

  • 701 Morning Street (Butler Home)

  • 796 Morning Street

  • 38-40 E New England Avenue

  • 49 E New England Avenue

  • 117 E New England Avenue

  • 123 E New England Avenue

  • 174 E New England Avenue

  • 25 W New England Avenue

  • 44 W New England Avenue

  • 123 W New England Avenue

  • 169 E North Street

  • 51 W North Street see Tuller/Archer House-portion of Tuller House is part of 51 W North Street

  • 7131 Olentangy River Road

  • 581 Oxford Street

  • 614 Oxford Street

  • 817 Oxford Street

  • 844 Oxford Street

  • 5797 Pioneer Ct (Riverlea)

  • 1028 Proprietors Street

  • 36 W Short Street see 615 High Street

  • 53 W Short Street

  • 59 W Short Street

  • 40 E South Street

  • 58 E South Street

  • 48 W South Street see Greer/Noble House

  • 131 W South Street

  •  286 W South Street (demo)

  • 318 W South Street

  • 410 W South Street see  Smoke Rise

  • 75 W Southington Avenue

  • 110 W Stafford Avenue

  • 5808 Westchester Ct (Riverlea)

  • 6653 Worthington Galena Road

   

• Sites by Name

   

  • Annex-See McConnell Arts Center

  • Antrim Park

  • Asher Brand House see Vertical File-People and Families-Brand, Asher

  • Banks

  • Beers Tavern

  • Birdsong-See President’s House

  • Bishop-Noble House-see Greer Noble House

  • Bishop-Webster-Lehman House

  • Boarding House

  • Brown Fruit Farm

  • Brundage Tavern

  • Central Hotel see Worthington Inn

  • Chase Houses (Bishop Chase)

  • Chase Tavern

  • City Hall (0lder) see Griswold Center

  • Demas Adams House

  • Don Scott Field

  • Dublin Granville Road (Rt. 161)

  • Elias Lewis House

  • Gingerbread House see Russell House

  • Green Gables see Russell House

  • Glengary Park-see Vertical File-Neighboring History-Flint

  • Greer/Noble House

  • Griswold Center

  • Griswold Houses

  • Griswold Inn- Griswold Inn Historical Foundation

  • Hannah Bishop House

  • Hard House

  • Harding Hospital

  • Hart-Fay-Robinson House

  • Hartford Street

  • Hartford at Stafford Village

  • Henri Boyd Inn see Worthington Inn

  • High Banks Park 

  • High Road Gallery see also Sidney Brown House

  • High Street and minor buildings

  • Horace Wright House-see also Sharon Memorial Hall

  • Jeffers Mound

  • Jones Building –see 691-693 High Street

  • Jewett Road/315 Upgrade Report

  • Kilbourn Commercial Building and Kilbourn House

  • Kilbourne Memorial Library see also Library Worthington Public Libraries

  • Kingsley Ray House

  • Lake Trezavant see Vertical File -Neighboring History-Flint-Glengary Park

  • Ladd Mattoon House

  • Leasure Drug Store-see 635 High Street

  • Library-Worthington Public Libraries see also Kilbourne Memorial

  • Library

  • McConnell Arts Center

  • Masonic Lodge

  • Mattoon House see Ladd Mattoon House

  • Maynard House

  • Melbourne Village see Vertical File-People and Families- Middleton, Myra

  • Middleton Place see Vertical File-People and Families-Middleton, Myra

  • Moses Wright Nature Area-see also People and Families-Wright James E-See also Past Perfect REF 00161

  • National Registry of Historical Places

  • Ohio Railway Museum see also Vertical File-Worthington History-Railroads & Interurban

  • Old Rectory

  • Olentangy River and Olentangy River Road (Flood Control see Vertical File-Worthington History-Flood Control)

  • Orange Johnson House see File 4

  • Ozem Gardner House see also Vertical File- Worthington History-Black

  • History-Underground Rail Road

  • Pinney Houses

  • Pioneer Theatre see 671-673 High Street

  • Post Offices see 635 High Street-see also Vertical File-Worth. History-Post Offices

  • Potter Wright House see 174 E New England Avenue

  • President’s House-Birdsong

  • Real Estate Listings-1989

  • Relocated Structures

  • Ripley House-see also Vertical File-Obituaries-Chet Bennett, MD

  • Rush Creek see Vertical File-Worthington History-Subdivisions-Rush Creek

  • Russell House-Gingerbread House-Green Gables see also People and Families Russell, Mark and Mary

  • Sharon Memorial Hall- Horace Wright House

  • Sharon Township Hall

  • Sidney Brown House-see also High Road Gallery

  • Skeele House

  • Smokerise on the Olentangy

  • Snow Drug Store see 635 High Street

  • Snow House

  • Stafford Village see Hartford at Stafford Village

  • Step by Step Academy-see Harding Hospital

  • Stritmatter House-see Greer/Noble House

  • Toll Gate Condominiums

  • Topping House

  • Trophy House

  • Travis Scott House

  • Tuller/Archer House

  • Turk/Gilkey House

  • Twin Oaks

  • Vest/Park House

  • Veterans Memorial see Village Green

  • Village Green-Veterans Memorial

  • Water Tower

  • Water Works-Granville Road

  • Whieldon House

  • Wilcox Farm House

  • Wiley House see Chase Tavern

  • Worthington Community Center

  • Worthington Foods-see Vertical File-Worthington History-Businesses

  • Worthington Hardware see Vertical File-Worthington History-Businesses- Worthington Hardware

  • Worthington Inn

  • Worthington Mall (Shops at Worthington Place)

  • WRFD Radio Station

  • Wright, Horace house see Sharon Memorial Hall

  • Wright, Potter House see 174 W New England Avenue

  • York County Club